Mansourieh Powerlines… All’s Well That Ends Well?

What a difference a week makes. The high voltage power lines cutting across the Mansourieh skyline are well on their way to completion. People’s fears have been allayed, hot tempers have cooled, politicians intervened, speeches were made, selfies were taken, and it’s as if nothing ever happened. 

While I am a strong supporter of people’s right to protest in a democratic society, I would have liked to see a better organized protest movement with far less friction with security forces and something approaching a well thought out rational strategy. Simply saying “it shall not pass!” and going toe to toe with politicians and governments carrying the banner of the public good is simply not a sustainable strategy or a winnable fight. The supposed public good seems to make villains out of anyone who opposes it.



From the start, when the pylons first started to pop up in and around Mansourieh in the early 2000s, protestors would routinely aim to disrupt work on the pylons and make themselves heard very loudly indeed all to draw media attention to the supposed health risks of high voltage lines passing overhead. Claiming high voltage power lines causes cancer was an unprovable claim even back then. The real reason we never wanted these high voltage lines in “our neighborhood”, and I probably speak for many other property owners in this and any other area, is property values which will no doubt be adversely affected. No one wants to open their window to see pylons and powerlines stretching before them blocking their view.  

Obviously, everyone wants a better connected electrical grid in Lebanon and we all hope this is just one of many measures the government will take to ensure we finally have 24-hour electrical power, but protests could have at least sought to achieve some sort of compensation for property owners. The government offering to buy properties in close proximity of the power lines is not a solution, many don’t trust the government will pay a fair market price, others simply do not want to leave. The neighborhood is more than just a collection of buildings, its home for many, a community bound together now by a shared struggle. If residents sell up and leave, that community would be greatly diminished, there are schools, a church, friendships, family, leaving is not an option for many.

However, in ten or twenty years’ time some may choose to sell up and move away anyway upon retirement, there is no question that property prices then will have appreciated considerably, but not as much as other similar properties not in the immediate vicinity of high voltage power lines. 

For many middle-class families living in this area, their homes are the most valuable thing they own, it is not just a shelter it is an investment. Realty prices in Lebanon in close proximity to the capital will only go up and for many this appreciation in prices is their big pay out. The powerlines and pylons will no doubt take a bite out of home prices. This may not be a life-threatening issue, like cancer from electromagnetic waves, but it’s still a serious issue. The question is who will care to compensate home owners now that Mansourieh protestors have been vilified and appear as if they don’t want Lebanon to have 24-hour electrical power?

Sometimes protests can backfire if there is no rational guidance behind them.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Orosdi-Back: A lost Beyrouth department store from an elegant age

Image
My mother told me it was located on ‘ Banks Street ’ in Down Town Beirut , the road that leads up to Riad el Solh Square . On most maps the street is also named after Riad el Solh. The store was located opposite Bank Intra, or so I was told. Presumably the location of the store was indicative of the high end goodies on sale inside. The closest comparison to Orosdi Back is the old Allied’s department store in Dubai , for those who remember Dubai in the 1980s. But Orosdi Back was a store from a different age, an age of elegance as opposed to the vulgar modern excesses of the nouveau-riche, something Beirut ’s Down Town is synonymous with! A wonderful blog dubbed ‘language hat’ published some information about the founders of this chain of department stores. According to the blog the chain of stores came about as a result of a partnership between Adolf Orosdi, a Hungarian army officer and his sons who opened a clothing store in Galata in 1855, and the Back family, who were Aust...
Read more

A Reluctant Resistance: Will They, Won't They Strike, Who Knows

Image
It’s hard for anyone to admit that they have wasted their life believing in an idea that was unrealistic and naïve even at its inception. The idea that Palestine could be liberated is one such idea that just won’t die, it keeps recirculating and reinfecting us with hope. Every 20 or 30 years some regional power decides to use this idea of liberation to achieve some kind of political success over the populations of countries in its region that it wishes to dominate.   Palestine is the perfect idea and cause, pure and good and just, just like the tale of the crucified Jesus. A story of gross injustice and cruelty heaped on a man preaching a new age religion. Same with the plight of the Palestinian people, gross injustice and cruelty. Jesus actually preached and healed and drove out demons in the very environs over which fanatical Western Jews are fighting and burning out farmers and villagers of the West Bank who have more Semitic and Canaanite DNA than many European Jews that ru...
Read more

Palestine's 100 Years War: How Our Militant Past Predicts Our Future

Image
Palestine’s 100 Years War The Past Rarely Predicts the Future, Except in the Middle East   “Never think that war, no matter how necessary, nor how justified, is not a crime.” — Ernest Hemingway, 1946   For as long as I can remember my region has been at war. Everyone alive today can attest to the veracity of such a statement. We cheer the men at arms as they go off to fight, we condemn the failure to find a peaceful solution, we admire the fighter, we condemn the terrorist. We are the same people, the great mass of seated spectators, they whom we cheer and condemn, are also the same, the same breed of angry and desperate men and who can blame them, their lives have been hell.   Searching the vast archives of the internet for one of my own, a distant cousin who was one of those angry desperate men, I found an article dated March 22, 1973, in the El Paso Herald-Post titled “Middle East prediction: the worst is yet to come”. It was earie and ...
Read more